Talk:Tooru Mutsuki/@comment-2.110.227.10-20141205163818/@comment-142.105.20.200-20141210074127

I'm sorry, but your reasoning is too weak to believe completely. My theory doesn't have to be true, but it isn't wrong either(yet) but until it is I will preach it until there isn't a hint of doubt in Mutsuki's character. No Ishida doesn't have to be blantant about it, but there isnt enough info to go on. So you can just randomly hate your established gender automatically and jump at the chance to live as a man when your family gets massacred out of nowhere? What.

1. I don't care about the trans thing, I just want to know WHY someone would choose to do that, it's too random to comprehend, that is, assuming they had a reason in the first place. What you're suggesting is that they have been feeling like that their entire life, but.. how can we know that? You're assuming it, and that closes out other options. So you're saying there is absolutely no chance for Mutsuki to be a rape victim? If I recall, Mutsuki seemed familiar with how Torso targets women, signaling a previous encounter with "predators". I merely combined this with her obsession with being seen as a male, and not just a male but a powerful figure. Sorry if I connected the dots wrong.

2,6 Trans people are not the only ones who cover up their feminine apperance lmao, did you know that they have been doing that since the dawn of time? For example, in the middle east, women were not allowed to go outside without covering their faces up as it was considered unethical and agaisnt the law, bad example but there are others that are more positive.

3-5 Not sure how long Mutsuki has been living as a man but it couldnt have been anymore than what? Around 5 years or so? Just long enough to get put in the academy and recruited on a team. Um, of course his team acknowledges him as a man, he hasn't told anyone of his actual origin besides the people that took him in and Torso, although indirectly. You expect them to know when Mutsuki has been doing this for years? He is a male on paper, so only people like Torso (who wasn't sure until he confirmed it for himself) knew the truth. What if Mutsuki is intentionally trying to be as masculine as possible after an event that shaped her views on herself?

Before you tell me how Mutsuki is a trans, tell me how my theory is wrong please, because you havent done that yet. Do I need to draw a picture or something? Because I can do that.

Let me put it this way, let's say something bad happened to Mutsuki right? After that event, she decided it would be easier for her to live as a man, probably for her own safety, now this might be right and it might be wrong, but its a hell of a lot easier to believe then someone who just got their entire family slaughtered to just easily say (oh hey I see an opprotunity to change my gender and my name). That chapter was vague as hell, and it might possibly be a trap to make the fandom go crazy. Also, when Torso found out Mutsuki was a female, Mutsuki overreacted. Strangely, Mutsuki still has a lot of female mannerisms, why then does she want to be seen as a man?

The main problem with the trans thing is the (why). You are just giving out a clinical term, screw that, there's no proof she has always been feeling like that. That chapter showed a younger Mutsuki, possibly in her late teens/young adulthood, so there is some room for my theory, barely but just enough to hover around. But if that's all they have to show about Mutsuki's past, then yes, she is a trans (until something else turns up..).