Board Thread:Wiki Discussions/@comment-27247962-20170311200423/@comment-31190419-20170311222015

By your own rules, Tatara should be considered unknown, unless you arbitrarily decide to call it a "death scene" when all we know is that he was defeated and was losing consciousness. Eto actually said that she was going to die yet she was kept unknown. Shachi also was losing consciousness in a similar matter.

Having a ghoul lie on the ground passed out is never a reliable indicator of death, so calling him a "corpse" is missing the mark, as there is not anything particularly gory about the state of his body.

And of course there is the contradicting information in Chapter 92  (the idea of him forgetting to draw Tatara while showing all the small fries is more hopeful than Arima/Matsuri being alive), where Ishida intentionally  didn't show Tatara in the same area where he was laying on the ground. T he idea of him forgetting to draw Tatara while showing all the small fries is more hopeful than Hairu/Arima/Matsuri being alive. Whether or not he was supposed to be covered up by Mutsuki's body, Mutsuki mentions nothing about seeing him, and he was the top target. This is clearly contradicting the idea of him being dead, even if you believe other information is indicative of him being dead. If he was lying on the ground looking as he did, the Qs would have no reason to believe he was dead, so Mutsuki would at least make sure to finish him off, as he was the top priority target of the entire invasion. But Mutsuki only reacted to seeing Owl and Floppy.

I explain this all a little more clearly here:

http://i.imgur.com/5fwiLBc.jpg

The thing with Matsuri is that there is no reason to believe the narrator is unreliable, and being "torn to ribbons" is a very visual decription which doesn't need a picture.

IMO: Tatara, Shachi, Chino should all be unknown, while Matsuri should be dead.

I've also seen people theorize that Ayato/Touka's mom is alive here. I haven't really looked into it but it may be worth an unknown status. https://mangahelpers.com/forum/threads/the-true-fate-of-the-kirishima-family.3005416/