Talk:Hairu Ihei/@comment-80.116.115.96-20151010075449/@comment-26897019-20151010100732

Adding on the latest block of text: By your logic all ghouls should be killed to put them out of the misery of living as ghouls. They have to eat humans, so you should therefore pity their existance and kill them to save them from the pitiful lives they lead. That is the logic I'm drawing from your statement.

Hairu might not be a child. But she's barely a women. She's 20. The quinx are the same age as her and they get much more pity. We don't know enough about Ihei to make a proper judgement on her character. She's killed many ghouls with a smile on her face. But so have many ghouls killed humans with a smile on their face. Aogiri, Uta, even Tsukiyama. They've all killed and hurt people with smiles drawn across their faces. Tsukiyama has killed people and caused more pain that nessicary to his 'food', is he too not at fault and should be killed?

And if the CCG didn't exist: humans would likely be exinct in the tg universe. The ccg exist to create a ghoul-free world so humans don't live in fear of being eaten by ghouls. Yes we call know the ccg has immense amounts of shady immoral dealing going on both in private and in public, but it's undeniable 'they're nessicary for humans society in it's current stance. 'Most, in fact all people would not like the idea of having to live in society knowing someone else might eat them. We can argue about co-existance all we want but problems still exist with that. Exterminating ghouls is the plan that most humans would agree to. Not to the sadistic extremes the ccg can go to, but nevertheless humans would undeniably not want ghouls wandering about waiting to eat them.

I do agree with you that Ihei probably would be better off dead in the fact she would be free, but by a story stand point, I doubt Ishida has killed her off yet. The fact he only shows us Ihei being pierced, and not her actually dying, as well as her charcater bio being released, suggest to be she will live, or at least be a big part of the story later to come, perhaps in a fashion similar to Mado Kureo.