Thread:Unok/@comment-24259054-20141012160800/@comment-3544775-20141014003430

It's preferable if discussions happen in the forum, due to people commenting a lot and that can create mess in the articles comments. But disabling them will mean those people will likely continue with talk pages, which will become even bigger mess as talk pages require you to add headings, sign comments. A lot of users won't do that and it will become even bigger mess. Just look here - http://tokyoghoul.wikia.com/wiki/Talk:Tokyo_Ghoul_Wiki no one used headings, some didn't sign their comments, they also don't know how to properly reply to a comment there. In my opinion that's harder to read and follow, especially when multiple people do it around the same time.

In order for the people to move commenting in the forums, it will require some activity to start first. I have added Forum Activity on the main page, so that more people to notice there are forums, but until people start commenting there, most will prefer to comment in the comments, since majority do it there.

I'm not sure if the 2nd anon user commenting here, was "for" or "against" comments, but some people come here not to edit. They are here to look up for info, talk, etc. Around the 11/12th episode of the anime (and end of the manga), the wiki was getting 1~1.4 million views per week. Not everyone was here to help editing, most were to complain about the story.