Talk:Ken Kaneki/@comment-3173617-20160920234705/@comment-76.5.87.80-20160922020023

^ You seem overly defensive. If someone presents a theory and it's clearly bunk, it deserves to be called out as such, regardless of who is posting it. If said person continuously posits theories that are, again, clearly bunk, then naturally they're going to be criticized for it. That's not "hating," that's how these things work. Your one example of a semi-plausible (this I will grant you) theory is not enough to cover the multitude of her clearly impossible hypotheticals. As I said, I enjoy her off the wall theories, but they deserve to be criticized. If we created a safe zone for Val, where she could just post her theories without taking any criticism, it would defeat the entire purpose of her posting them in the first place.